In the rapidly evolving world of electric vehicles (EVs), the competition is heating up, especially in the budget segment. Two standout contenders in this space are the MG Comet vs Tata Tiago EV. With similar price points and ranges, choosing between them can be a tough decision. In this detailed comparison.
We delve into various aspects to determine which one emerges as the best budget-friendly EV.
Table of Contents
Pricing and Battery Options:
- MG Comet: Priced between Rs 7.98 lakh-9.98 lakh with a 17.3kWh battery.
- Tata Tiago EV: Two variants – MR version (19.2kWh, Rs 8.69 lakh-9.29 lakh) and LR version (24kWh, Rs 10.24 lakh-11.54 lakh).
Design:
- MG Comet: Radical two-door, four-seater with a cube-like silhouette; India’s smallest passenger vehicle.
- Tata Tiago EV: Conventional two-box design, appearing relatively dated compared to the MG.
Interior:
- MG Comet: Futuristic, minimal, and spacious interior; high-quality build, but limited comfort in the front seats.
- Tata Tiago EV: Solidly built cabin, albeit relatively bland; comfortable seats and better practicality with a larger boot (240 litres).
Features:
- MG Comet: 10.25-inch twin-screen setup with connected car tech, wireless Android Auto, and Apple CarPlay; lacks in sound quality.
- Tata Tiago EV: Practical cabin design, comfier seats, and better storage solutions; lacks flashy displays but excels in functionality.
Performance:
- MG Comet: Urban runabout with three driving modes (Eco, Normal, Sports); modest 42hp/110Nm motor.
- Tata Tiago EV: Responsive 74hp motor; superior handling, dynamics, and performance, especially in Sport mode.
Range and Charging:
- Range: MG Comet (17.3kWh) outperforms in efficiency; 193km on a full charge. Tiago EV (24kWh) manages 187km.
- Comet – 3 hours for 20-80% (AC fast-charger),
- Tiago EV – 1 hour for the same (DC fast charging).
MG Comet vs Tata Tiago EV which one I should buy?
Both the MG Comet vs Tata Tiago EV are excellent choices for entry-level electric vehicles, but the best one for you depends on your individual needs and priorities. Here’s a breakdown of their key features to help you decide:
MG Comet:
Pros:
- Compact and nimble: Perfect for city driving and navigating tight spaces.
- Unique design: Eye-catching and futuristic, stands out from the crowd.
- Higher top speed: Can reach 102 km/h compared to Tiago’s 120 km/h.
- More efficient: 11.17 km/kWh efficiency versus Tiago’s 7.77 km/kWh.
- Sport mode: Adds a touch of excitement to your driving experience.
Cons:
- Smaller boot space: Only 143L compared to Tiago’s 242L.
- No rear doors: Might be inconvenient for families or frequent passengers.
- Less powerful: 40hp versus Tiago’s 74hp.
- No fast charging: Lacks DC fast charging capability.
Tata Tiago EV:
Pros:
- More spacious: Five-seater with comfortable interiors and bigger boot space.
- More powerful: Offers better performance and faster acceleration.
- Fast charging: Significantly reduces charging time.
- More practical: Rear doors and larger boot make it more versatile for various uses.
Cons:
- Larger and less nimble: Less suited for narrow streets and congested areas.
- Lower top speed: May not be ideal for highway driving.
- Less efficient: Requires more energy to travel the same distance.
- Conventional design: Looks similar to the regular Tiago, not as distinctive.
Also Read – Top 5 Affordable EV Cars In 2024: Starting From 8 Lakhs
Here are some additional factors to consider:
- Budget: Both cars fall within the same price range, but the Tiago might be slightly cheaper depending on the variant.
- Driving habits: If you mainly drive in the city, the Comet’s efficiency and agility might be advantageous. For frequent highway trips or family outings, the Tiago’s space and power would be preferable.
- Charging infrastructure: If fast charging is crucial, the Tiago is the only option.
- Personal preference: Ultimately, choose the car that you find more appealing in terms of design, features, and driving experience.
Conclusion
In this head-to-head comparison, the Tata Tiago EV emerges as the more compelling choice for budget-conscious EV enthusiasts. It excels in driving dynamics, practicality, and features, offering a well-rounded package.
The MG Comet, with its unique design and spacious interior, is undoubtedly charming but falls short in key areas. As a primary urban runabout, the Tiago EV stands out, while the Comet remains an intriguing option for those seeking a distinctive and cool secondary choice. Ultimately, it’s the Tata Tiago EV that gets our vote for its overall appeal and practicality in the budget EV market.
Also Read: From Tata Curvv EV To Hyundai Creta EV: Upcoming EV In 2024
Thank you so much for reading. If you have any query please let us know through below comment box. We appreciate you valuable time.
Frequently Asked Question
MG Comet EV vs Tata Tiago EV price comparison
MG Comet EV is likely more affordable, starting at around ₹7.98 lakh, while Tata Tiago EV may start closer to ₹8.69 lakh. Both cars likely offer multiple variants with varying features and prices.
Which EV offers better range, MG Comet or Tata Tiago?
Tata Tiago EV might offer a longer range of around 187 km, while MG Comet EV might offer around 193 km. However, MG Comet EV could be more efficient in city driving.
Is MG Comet EV faster than Tata Tiago EV?
MG Comet EV might have a slight edge in acceleration, but both cars likely offer similar performance levels. Feature sets could vary, with MG focusing on connectivity and Tata emphasizing safety.
Is MG Comet EV spacious enough for a family?
MG Comet EV is a compact two-door car, more suitable for individuals or couples. Tata Tiago EV, being a four-door hatchback, might offer better space for families.
Which EV is better for city driving, MG Comet or Tata Tiago?
MG Comet EV might excel in city driving due to its compact size and maneuverability. However, Tata Tiago EV could be a better choice for longer trips or carrying more passengers and cargo.
2 thoughts on “MG Comet vs Tata Tiago EV: A Comprehensive Budget EV Comparison”